[Enforcement library](/enforcement)

# Chisholm v. BBC: CIPA claims fail under New York law, but a VPPA claim over trackers that ignored the opt-out goes ahead

Five website visitors alleged that tracking tools from Piano, ScoreCard and Google Ads on the BBC's US website kept sending their interactions, identifiers, email addresses and video titles to those companies after they clicked "Do not sell or share my personal information" and rejected non-required cookies. On 5 November 2026 Judge J. Paul Oetken granted BBC Global News US's motion to dismiss in part. The CIPA and intrusion upon seclusion claims were dismissed because New York law governs and gives no private right of action; the federal Wiretap Act, UCL, New York GBL, fraud and unjust enrichment claims were also dismissed. The VPPA claim survives because the trackers allegedly received plain-text email addresses together with the titles of videos watched.

## Key facts

- **Regulator or court:** US District Court, Southern District of New York
- **Jurisdiction:** New York, US
- **Framework:** VPPA (18 U.S.C. § 2710); Wiretap Act (18 U.S.C. § 2511); CIPA §§ 631 and 638; California UCL; New York GBL §§ 349-350
- **Record date:** 2026-11-05
- **Procedural status:** Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part on 5 November 2026; VPPA claim proceeds; CIPA, Wiretap Act and other claims dismissed

Visitors said the BBC's US website kept feeding Piano, ScoreCard and Google Ads after they clicked "Do not sell or share" and rejected cookies. A New York federal judge threw out the California wiretap claims because New York law applies, but kept the Video Privacy Protection Act claim alive.

[Start a free scan](/run-free-codebase-scan)

- **Court**: US District Court for the Southern District of New York (Judge J. Paul Oetken)
- **Case number**: No. 1:26-cv-00809 (JPO)
- **Parties**: Chris Chisholm, Govind Ramabadran, Serge Belozerov, Kenneth Sale and David Ramirez, for a putative class, v. BBC Global News US, LLC
- **Laws**: VPPA; Wiretap Act; CIPA §§ 631 and 638; California UCL; New York GBL §§ 349-350; intrusion upon seclusion, fraud, unjust enrichment
- **Stage**: Opinion and order on the motion to dismiss the amended complaint (ECF No. 33), 5 November 2026: granted in part, denied in part
- **Amount**: None
- **Source review**: 13 November 2026

## The problem

BBC Global News US runs the BBC's US website, where visitors read articles and watch videos, and can subscribe with an email address or by paying. According to the amended complaint, even after visitors toggled off the sharing of their personal information and rejected all non-required cookies, the site kept sending data through tracking tools from Piano, ScoreCard and Google Ads. The data allegedly included clicks on links, forms and search bars, inferred characteristics such as age and preferences, device and browser type, email addresses and IP-based location ([opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766), Part I.A).

The five named plaintiffs, from Alaska, California, Massachusetts and New York, each clicked "Do not sell or share my personal information" when they visited the site again in connection with the investigation behind the suit. The plaintiffs also alleged that Piano and ScoreCard tell website operators their tools require notice and valid consent ([opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766), Parts I.A and I.B).

## What the court found

| Claim | Result and reason |
| --- | --- |
| CIPA §§ 631 and 638 | Dismissed. Under New York choice-of-law rules, conduct-regulating privacy laws follow where the conduct happened, and the complaint itself said BBC's decisions come from its New York office. New York's eavesdropping and pen register laws give private plaintiffs no right to sue |
| Choice-of-law clause in BBC's terms | Did not decide the question: it covered only "these Terms" (contract disputes), not privacy torts |
| Intrusion upon seclusion | Dismissed; New York does not recognize the tort |
| Wiretap Act | Dismissed. BBC was a party to visitors' communications with its own site, and the crime-tort exception failed because the alleged VPPA violation happened at the same moment as the interception |
| VPPA | Survives. Scrambled identifiers such as a user token are not personally identifiable under Solomon v. Flipps Media, but plain-text email addresses sent with video titles are; newsletter subscribers count as consumers under Salazar v. NBA |
| UCL, GBL and fraud | Dismissed for lack of actual injury; "loss of control" over data was not enough |
| Unjust enrichment | Dismissed as duplicating the other claims |
| Class action waiver in subscription terms | Left for class certification |

Sources: [opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766); [National Law Review summary, 11 November 2026](https://natlawreview.com/article/bbc-changes-channel-cipa-new-york-law-defeats-cipa-claims-against-bbc).

## Technical issue

- **Alleged behavior:** Piano, ScoreCard and Google Ads tags kept sending requests after a visitor clicked "Do not sell or share" and rejected non-required cookies.
- **Data (alleged):** on-page interactions, inferred age and preferences, device and browser details, IP-based location, email addresses and the titles of videos watched.
- **Identifiers:** the court treated a scrambled user token differently from a plain-text email address. Only the email address, sent alongside video titles, supported the VPPA claim.

**Inth's technical interpretation:** an opt-out link or Reject All button that does not change which tags load is the fact pattern behind both the consent claims and the VPPA claim here. Keep email addresses and other direct identifiers out of tracker payloads, especially on pages that play video.

Sample:

```ts
// Opt-out recorded, but tags keep firing with a plain-text email
consent.set({ saleOrShare: false, marketing: false });
piano.track({ email: user.email, video: video.title });

// Check the stored choice before any vendor call, and never send raw email
if (consent.allows('marketing') && consent.allows('saleOrShare')) {
  piano.track({ video: video.title });
}
```

## Timeline

| Date | Event |
| --- | --- |
| 30 January 2026 | Original complaint filed by Chisholm, Ramabadran, Belozerov and Ramirez |
| 1 May 2026 | BBC moves to dismiss the original complaint |
| 5 June 2026 | Amended complaint filed, adding Kenneth Sale (ECF No. 30) |
| 17 July 2026 | BBC moves to dismiss the amended complaint (ECF No. 33) |
| 5 November 2026 | Opinion and order: motion granted in part and denied in part; VPPA claim proceeds |

Dates from the [opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766), Part I.C.

## Outcome

The motion to dismiss was granted in part and denied in part. The VPPA claim goes forward and BBC must answer it; the other claims were dismissed ([opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766); [National Law Review](https://natlawreview.com/article/bbc-changes-channel-cipa-new-york-law-defeats-cipa-claims-against-bbc)). Whether the dismissed claims may be repleaded, and the next deadlines, were not confirmed from the sources reviewed. No liability has been found and no money has changed hands.

## What it cost

| Item | Amount | Source |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Damages or settlement | None so far | [Opinion](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766) |
| Defense costs | Not stated in the cited record |  |

## Why it matters

- **Where tracking decisions are made can decide which law applies.** For a New York company, CIPA claims failed because New York law governed, even for California visitors.
- **A choice-of-law clause limited to "these Terms" may not reach privacy claims.** BBC won on default choice-of-law rules, not on its own clause.
- **A broken opt-out still matters under the VPPA.** A consent defense is hard to argue when the opt-out allegedly did not work and email addresses went out with video titles.
- **This is one district court ruling.** It does not bind California courts and does not help companies that make tracking decisions in California.

Related pages: [CIPA § 631 wiretapping](/enforcement/laws/cipa-631-wiretapping).

## How Inth catches this

- **Consent banner**: Treats a Do Not Sell or Share click, Reject All and GPC as one stored choice and holds Piano, Google Ads and similar tags until that choice allows them.
- **Website audit**: Loads pages after an opt-out and after Reject All and records which tracker requests still fire and whether they carry email addresses or video titles.

### Out of reach

- Inth cannot decide which state's law applies to a claim, and it does not see server-side transfers to vendors after the browser request.

Consent records with the exact wording shown, choice, purpose, GPC state, country and policy version.

[Start a free scan](/run-free-codebase-scan)

## Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

### In the repository

- [ ] Confirm every analytics and ad tag checks the stored opt-out and cookie choice before it loads.
- [ ] Search tracker calls for email addresses or other direct identifiers, and remove or hash them per vendor rules.

### In the browser and network

- [ ] Click your Do not sell or share link and Reject All in a clean profile, then record every third-party request on article and video pages.
- [ ] Check whether any request carries a video title together with an identifier.

### With the people responsible

- [ ] Record where decisions about website tracking are made and by whom.
- [ ] Review whether the choice-of-law clause in your terms covers privacy claims, with counsel.

## Sources and limits

- [Opinion and order, 5 November 2026 (vLex)](https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/chisholm-v-bbc-glob-1139095766)
- [National Law Review (Troutman Amin, CIPAWorld), 11 November 2026](https://natlawreview.com/article/bbc-changes-channel-cipa-new-york-law-defeats-cipa-claims-against-bbc)
- [PACER Monitor case page](https://www.pacermonitor.com/public/case/62859535/Chisholm_et_al_v_BBC_Global_News_US,_LLC) (not opened)

Only the opening parts of the opinion (background and procedural history) were read on vLex; the holdings come from the National Law Review summary, which cites the opinion as 2026 WL 3362164. Facts about the website and trackers are the plaintiffs' allegations. Whether dismissal was with or without leave to amend, and BBC's answer deadline, were not confirmed.

Source review: 13 November 2026. This page describes the cited record and procedural stage. It does not audit the company's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.

## Related cases

[Every case in the Enforcement library](/enforcement)