[Enforcement library](/enforcement)

# Cookies before choice or after refusal: what the banner says versus what the browser stores

A banner can show the right choices while cookies are set on arrival or read after Reject. European regulators test the browser, not the banner, and these records show the fines that followed.

[Start a free scan](/run-free-codebase-scan)

## What the issue is

The issue has three moments: cookies placed before a visitor chooses, cookies set or read after Refuse all, and cookies still read after someone withdraws consent. Each is tested by watching the cookie jar and the requests, not by reading the banner text.

CNIL found that [SHEIN](/enforcement/shein)'s site placed cookies before consent and read or wrote cookies after refusal or withdrawal. In [Orange](/enforcement/orange), withdrawal had to stop cookie access, not just update the banner.

## Why regulators and plaintiffs care

The amounts are large: EUR 150 million for SHEIN, EUR 50 million for Orange and EUR 60 million for [Microsoft Bing](/enforcement/microsoft-bing), where CNIL also examined a cookie with several purposes.

Remediation is checked too. The Orange record notes that the cookie injunction was later closed following remediation. The [GDPR and ePrivacy cookie rules](/enforcement/laws/gdpr-and-eprivacy-cookies) page explains the legal basis.

## What to check in your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

### In the repository

- [ ] List every component that writes cookies or local storage, including pop-ups and A/B tools, with its consent category.
- [ ] Find any consent prompt outside the main consent manager.
- [ ] Check that withdrawal clears first-party cookies and stops further third-party requests.

### In the browser and network

- [ ] In a fresh profile, record traffic on arrival, after Refuse all and after accept then withdraw.
- [ ] Diff the cookie jar and Cookie headers between those states.
- [ ] Navigate and reload after withdrawal, then check again.

### With the people responsible

- [ ] Agree in writing which cookies you treat as exempt and why.
- [ ] Check that the settings layer names every third party that can set cookies.

## Cases in the library

3 cases in the library are tagged with this issue, newest first. Each page has the record, the source and its procedural status.

- [SHEIN](/enforcement/shein): Test cookies on arrival, after Reject all and after withdrawal. CNIL · Announced 3 September 2025 · CNIL sanction announced.
- [Orange](/enforcement/orange): Withdrawal had to stop cookie access, not just update the banner. CNIL · Decision 14 November 2024 · Fine imposed; cookie injunction closed on 11 September 2025.
- [Microsoft Bing](/enforcement/microsoft-bing): Make Reject as easy as Accept, and do not hide ad uses inside a security cookie. CNIL · Published 22 December 2022 · Sanction; specific injunction later satisfied.

## Related law pages

The laws most often cited in these cases:

- [GDPR and ePrivacy cookie rules](/enforcement/laws/gdpr-and-eprivacy-cookies): linked from 2 of the cases above

## Sources and limits

The sources for each case are on its case page. [Read how to use the library](/enforcement#how-to-read).

Source review: 19 October 2026. This page groups the cases Inth has tagged with this issue and summarises each record at its procedural stage. An allegation is not a finding, and a settlement does not establish liability after trial. Tentative rulings are labelled and may change at the hearing. Inth assigns the issue labels and implementation checks. It is not legal advice. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.

## Questions about cookies before choice or after refusal

Short answers drawn from the cases above.

### Are any cookies allowed before consent?

The rules allow storage that is strictly necessary for a service the visitor asked for, or for transmitting a communication. Which cookies qualify is a legal judgement; write it down before a regulator asks. See [GDPR and ePrivacy cookie rules](/enforcement/laws/gdpr-and-eprivacy-cookies).

### Is updating the banner state enough after withdrawal?

Not in [Orange](/enforcement/orange). CNIL looked at whether cookie access actually stopped.

### How do regulators test this?

The records describe checks of the browser: what is stored and sent on arrival, after refusal and after withdrawal.