Skip to content
Opens the cited record in a new tab

Bundeskartellamt v Meta: off-Facebook data needs separate consent

Facebook users once had to accept data from Instagram and from other sites and apps being linked to their account. Germany's competition authority banned that in 2019. The case closed in 2024 with remedies.

Regulator
Bundeskartellamt (Federal Cartel Office)
Law
German competition law (abuse of dominance), interpreted with the GDPR
Stage
Final. Case closed

The problem

Using Facebook required allowing Meta to collect data about users outside Facebook and link it to their account. That covered Meta's other services, such as Instagram, and data collected in third-party apps and on third-party websites. Users could "either agree to an almost limitless amount of data being combined or not use the social network at all".

What the regulator found

These are the authority's findings, now final, as described in its October 2024 press release.

  • The authority prohibited Facebook's terms that made using the network conditional on combining data from other sources.
  • Data could only be combined with the user's "distinct consent, which, however, could not be made a condition for using Facebook".
  • The Federal Court of Justice (2020) and the CJEU (2023) confirmed the authority's position on matters of principle.

Technical issue

The data from third-party sites and apps arrives through what Meta calls its Business Tools, such as the pixel and SDKs that site owners install. This case was about what Meta does with that data once it arrives, not about the sites that sent it.

Timeline

DateEvent
6 February 2019Bundeskartellamt decision; Meta appeals
2020Federal Court of Justice backs the authority in interim proceedings
7 June 2023Authority announces Meta's Accounts Centre
4 July 2023CJEU judgment in C-252/21
10 October 2024Meta withdraws its appeal; case closed and decision final

Outcome

  • An Accounts Centre that lets users choose which Meta services to connect.
  • "Cookie" settings in Facebook and Instagram that let users refuse linking of data from Business Tools on other sites and apps.
  • Facebook Login can still be used by people who refuse that linking.
  • Prominent notices for users who agreed to linking in the past, with direct links to the new settings.
  • Data combined for security purposes is kept only for a fixed, limited period.

What it cost

No fine. The cost was product changes and more than five years of proceedings.

Why it matters

For site owners the relevance is indirect. It explains why Meta users can now refuse the linking of pixel data, and it is background to the German damages claims over Meta's Business Tools. It does not remove a site owner's own duty to get consent before the pixel loads.

How Inth catches this

  • Consent banner

    Under the EU opt-in policy, optional tags wait until the visitor chooses. On withdrawal it sends the revocation to each integration and stops loading tags not yet loaded.

  • Website audit

    Records what loaded before a choice and after Reject, with page, time, region and consent state.

  • Code audit

    Flags a pull request that adds an advertising tag outside the consent check.

Out of reach

  • Inth works on your side of the pixel, not inside Meta. A browser observation cannot establish downstream use.

Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

0 of 3 done

In the repository

0 of 1 done

In the browser and network

0 of 1 done

With the people responsible

0 of 1 done

Sources and limits

Source review: 20 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit Meta's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.