Skip to content

Inth is now agentic by default. Use it from Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor.

See how
Opens the cited record in a new tab

Amazon (CNIL): ad cookies on every landing page, including the ones reached from an ad

Your banner has to appear, and hold tags back, on whatever page a visitor lands on first, not only the home page. CNIL's 2020 Amazon decision found that visitors who clicked an Amazon ad elsewhere and landed on a product page got advertising cookies with no banner at all.

Administrative fine
EUR35,000,000
Regulator
CNIL
Law
French Data Protection Act Article 82
Stage
Appeal rejected on 27 June 2022; injunction closed in 2021. CNIL decision

CNIL now publishes this decision without the company's name, as the decision provided after two years (CNIL sanctions list). The Conseil d'État judgment and the archived decision name Amazon. Article 82 says reading or writing on a device "may take place only if the subscriber or user has expressed, after receiving that information, his or her consent" (Article 82, CNIL translation in SAN-2025-005 ¶ 71). The information must cover the purpose and "the means at his disposal to oppose it".

The problem

Whether people typed amazon.fr or arrived on a product page from a search result or an ad, more than 40 advertising cookies were placed on their device before they did anything (SAN-2020-013 ¶ 87). The home-page banner said only: "En utilisant ce site, vous acceptez notre utilisation de cookies pour offrir et améliorer nos services" ("By using this site, you accept our use of cookies to provide and improve our services") (¶ 89). Ad-click arrivals saw no information at all (¶ 96). These are CNIL findings, upheld on appeal.

What the regulator found

BreachWhat Article 82 requiresWhat CNIL foundResult
Cookies before consentConsent before non-exempt cookiesMore than 40 advertising cookies on arrival on any path (¶ 87)Breach
Information on the home pageClear, complete information on purposes and how to refuse"Provide and improve our services" did not explain ad personalization; no means of refusal mentioned (¶¶ 89, 94–95)Breach
Information for ad-click arrivalsSameNo banner at all; cookies set "à leur insu" (without their knowledge) (¶¶ 96, 119)Breach; aggravating factor

Amazon argued that Luxembourg law let browser settings express consent, that an AdChoices icon offered control, and that most ad clickers were existing customers. CNIL rejected each point (¶¶ 82–84, 99–104).

Technical issue

  • Tools or vendors: Amazon's own advertising cookies and those of "une vingtaine" (about twenty) companies specializing in personalized advertising (¶ 121). The decision does not list cookie names.
  • Where: the amazon.fr home page and product pages reached from search results or ads on other sites (¶¶ 75, 87).
  • When: before any action, "fût-ce une simple poursuite de la navigation" (not even continued browsing, which the 2013 CNIL guidance had once accepted as consent) (¶ 89).
  • Scale: about 300 million Amazon identifiers assigned in France over nine months (¶ 123).
  • How it came to light: CNIL online inspections on 12 December 2019, 6 March 2020 and 19 May 2020, and an on-site inspection at Amazon Online France on 30 January 2020 (¶ 2). CNIL compared cookies set by the third-party site with those set on landing at amazon.fr to separate the two (¶ 75).

Inth's technical interpretation: the failure is architectural. The notice lived on one page while the tags lived in the shared layout that every page renders, so any entry point other than the home page skipped the notice and still fired the tags. Deep links from ads and search are a large share of e-commerce traffic, which is why CNIL treated them as the more serious case.

Illustrative pattern, not the defendant's code.
// Bad: ad tags in the shared layout; the notice only renders on the home page
export default function RootLayout({ children }) {
  return (<html><body>
    <Script src="https://ads.example-network.com/tag.js" strategy="afterInteractive" />
    {children}
  </body></html>);
}
// app/page.tsx: <CookieNotice text="By using this site you accept cookies." />

Timeline

DateEvent
12 December 2019 to 19 May 2020Three online inspections and one on-site inspection (¶ 2)
September 2020Amazon changes amazon.fr so no cookie is set before consent (¶¶ 82, 128)
7 December 2020Fine and injunction
8 July 2021Injunction closed as satisfied (CNIL)
27 June 2022Conseil d'État rejects Amazon's appeal (No 451423)

Outcome

CNIL fined Amazon Europe Core €35 million, citing the amount of advertising data collected, the roughly €7.7 billion 2019 turnover of the company and the "avantage financier certain" (definite financial benefit) of setting cookies before anyone could refuse (¶¶ 124–125). Even after the September 2020 changes, the new banner still did not explain ad purposes, so CNIL ordered Amazon, within three months and under €100,000 per day of delay, to inform visitors on their first page, whatever it was, of the purposes of all consent-based cookies and how to refuse them (operative part).

CNIL closed the injunction on 8 July 2021. It noted that it had not yet tested whether refusal was as easy as acceptance under its September 2020 guidelines, and reserved the right to check (CNIL closure notice).

The Conseil d'État rejected Amazon's challenge to CNIL's jurisdiction, the procedure and the amount, finding no need to refer questions to the Court of Justice (No 451423 ¶¶ 16, 21, 31–32).

What it cost

ItemAmount or term
Administrative fineEUR 35,000,000
Penalty paymentsEUR 100,000 per day threatened; none accrued, injunction met
AppealRejected, 27 June 2022
Payment recordNot stated in the cited record

Why it matters

CNIL adopted this decision on the same day as its first cookie fine against Google. The Conseil d'État judgment confirmed that an EU company with a French sales and advertising establishment answers to CNIL for cookies on its French site, which CNIL relied on again against SHEIN (SAN-2025-005 ¶ 46). It is separate from the Luxembourg GDPR proceedings about Amazon's ad processing, which the Conseil d'État noted (No 451423 ¶¶ 22–25). See cookies before choice and GDPR and ePrivacy cookie rules.

How Inth catches this

  • Code audit

    Flags a pull request that adds an advertising script to a shared layout outside the consent check.

  • Website audit

    Records ad-domain requests on any page, including deep-linked product pages, with page, time, region and consent state.

  • Consent banner

    Under the EU opt-in policy, nothing optional loads until the visitor chooses, on whichever page they land.

Out of reach

  • Inth cannot see cookies set by the third-party site that ran your ad before the visitor arrived; CNIL also excluded those from this case.

Consent records show each choice, country and policy; runtime observations show which entry page fired which domain.

Start a free scan

Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

0 of 8 done

In the repository

0 of 3 done

In the browser and network

0 of 3 done

With the people responsible

0 of 2 done

Sources and limits

Source review: 17 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit Amazon's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.