What the regulator found
The proposed resolution of 1 March 2024 found three failings, which together breach LSSI Article 22(2):
- Cookies before consent. Google cookies (SOCS, NID, CONSENT, AEC) and third-party cookies from Tealium, Akamai and Qubit were used before any choice.
- No real refusal or granular choice. The panel's only action was <<Si, acepto>>, and it set the same cookies with every optional group switched off.
- No withdrawal. After consenting, switching groups back to off and saving still left non-essential cookies in use.
NH argued the Google cookies supported reCAPTCHA bot detection and were exempt under Article 29 Working Party guidance, and that the remaining cookies were technical or functional. The AEPD rejected this: the Google cookies collect information used for other purposes, and the Tealium, Akamai and Qubit cookies were used without consent. On the banner's first-layer text, the AEPD found it identified purposes and how to accept, configure or reject, and did not itself breach the rules.