Outcome
The court certified this class under Rule 23(b)(3) and (b)(2): "All persons in the United States who, from February 17, 2020 through the date on which class notice is disseminated, had the same email address associated with a subscription to webmd.com and a Facebook account, and for whom there is associated Event Data in the possession of Meta Platforms, Inc. showing their video-viewing behavior on webmd.com" (op. at 5, 27, 30).
- Ascertainability: WebMD holds the subscriber emails and Meta holds the Event Data, so membership can be determined objectively. WebMD's worries about 404 pages or shared computers were "entirely speculative" (op. at 9–14).
- Numerosity: WebMD's records showed at least 550,213 subscriber emails with video activity in 2021 and 2022 alone, and 269,189 who reached video through newsletter links (op. at 15).
- Commonality: defining the class by Meta's data "appears to circumvent" individual differences in privacy settings: "If Meta has Event Data showing that a particular user watched a particular video on webmd.com, that is absolute proof of a violation because there is no other way that Meta would have that data" (quoting plaintiff, op. at 22).
- Typicality: WebMD pointed to a
has_user_PII_data column showing "0" and "FALSE" in the plaintiff's Meta data. The court read that column as reflecting how Meta matched the record, not whether PII was disclosed (op. at 23). - Injunction class: WebMD "could be enjoined to either stop using the Pixel in this violative manner or to obtain informed consent compliant with the VPPA" (op. at 29).
The order is a district court ruling and does not bind other courts. Plaintiffs' counsel in other VPPA cases now cite it as the contested certification that succeeded, against denials in Martinez v. D2C, In re Hulu and Therrien v. Hearst (Limited Run Games fee memorandum, ECF 23-1 at 10).