Outcome
Standing. Disclosure of viewing information to a third party without consent "has a 'close relationship'" to the tort of public disclosure of private facts, so the injury is concrete (slip op. at 5).
Consumer. "The phrase 'goods or services' in the VPPA is not cabined to audiovisual goods or services, but also reaches the NBA's online newsletter" (slip op. at 23). Giving an email address, IP address and cookies in exchange for the newsletter made Salazar a subscriber. The court expressly left PII for later: "we need not and do not explore that argument in this appeal" (slip op. at 35 n.10). It also left the NBA's consent-by-privacy-policy argument to the district court (slip op. at 12 n.4).
On remand. Judge Rochon applied Solomon and Hughes, held that "an ordinary person would not plausibly be able to identify Plaintiff's video-watching habits as a result of the Pixel transmissions", and dismissed with prejudice (remand op. at 11). She rejected the argument that a web search or ChatGPT could decode the Facebook ID (op. at 10).
The consumer holding binds courts in the Second Circuit and is half of the 2-2 split the Supreme Court is resolving in Salazar v. Paramount.