Skip to content
Opens the cited record in a new tab

Planet49 (BGH Cookie-Einwilligung II): a pre-ticked box is not consent

A 2013 online sweepstakes used a pre-ticked box to get consent for advertising cookies. After a CJEU ruling, Germany's Federal Court of Justice held that this was not valid consent.

Regulator
Bundesgerichtshof (BGH), after CJEU C-673/17
Law
Telemedia Act §15(3) read with ePrivacy Directive Article 5(3); GDPR Article 4(11)
Stage
Final. Judgment

The problem

To enter the sweepstakes, users had to tick at least one of two boxes. One, already ticked, allowed a tracking service called Remintrex to set cookies linked to the user's name and address for targeted advertising. The other, unticked, allowed marketing by sponsors chosen from a list of 57 companies, or by the organizer's choice. The court held neither was valid consent.

What the court found

These are court findings, from the BGH press release. Inth translated the German.

  • Cookies: consent through a pre-ticked box unfairly disadvantaged users, both under the law at the time and under the GDPR. Cookies used to build user profiles for advertising or market research need the user's consent, following the CJEU's answer to the BGH's questions.
  • The random ID stored in the cookie and linked to the user's registration details was a pseudonym, so profiling with it fell under the consent rule.
  • Marketing calls: consent must be informed and "for the specific case" (translated), which means it must be clear which companies' products or services it covers. The form was designed to confront users with a laborious selection from the partner list so they would leave the choice to the organizer. Without that knowledge, there was no valid consent.

Technical issue

The pre-ticked box's own explanation said the cookies would get a random ID tied to the registration data, so visits to Remintrex partner sites, the products viewed and any purchase could be recorded.

Illustrative pattern, not the defendant's code.
<!-- Risky: consent box ticked by default -->
<input type="checkbox" name="ad_cookies" checked>

<!-- Safer: unticked; tracking waits for an active choice -->
<input type="checkbox" name="ad_cookies">

Timeline

DateEvent
September 2013Sweepstakes runs online
First instanceRegional court enjoins both consents and awards warning-letter costs
AppealHigher regional court overturns the cookie part; both sides appeal to the BGH
5 October 2017BGH refers questions to the CJEU
1 October 2019CJEU rules in C-673/17 that a pre-ticked box is not valid consent
28 May 2020BGH restores the first-instance injunction

Outcome

The BGH dismissed the organizer's appeal, allowed the consumer federation's appeal on the cookie consent and restored the first-instance ruling. The organizer must not use either consent wording and must pay the warning-letter costs. The decision is final.

What it cost

No fine. An injunction, the warning-letter costs and about seven years of litigation.

Why it matters

This is the foundation case for active opt-in to advertising cookies, at both EU and German level. Every banner that requires a click before tracking traces back to it. It also shows that a long partner list can defeat consent if it is built to discourage reading.

How Inth catches this

  • Consent banner

    Under the EU opt-in policy, optional tags wait until the visitor chooses.

  • Code audit

    Flags a pull request that adds an advertising tag, ad-cookie write or storage write outside the consent check.

Out of reach

  • Sign-up and sweepstakes forms are outside the banner. Pre-ticked boxes in your own forms must be fixed in your own code.

Consent records show each visitor's choice, country and policy.

Start a free scan

Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

0 of 4 done

In the repository

0 of 2 done

In the browser and network

0 of 1 done

With the people responsible

0 of 1 done

Sources and limits

Source review: 20 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit the organizer's current systems. Inth translated the German quotes and wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.