Outcome
The Ninth Circuit held that the district court should have asked "whether a reasonable user reading them would think that he or she was consenting to the data collection" (Op. p. 17), and instead let the case turn on a technical question. "[T]he governing standard is what a 'reasonable user' of a service would understand they were consenting to, not what a technical expert would" (Op. p. 18). Read together, Google's general policy and the Chrome notice's "affirmative statement" meant a reasonable user "would not necessarily understand" they had consented (p. 21). The court added that the reasonable user is not "an experienced business lawyer" (p. 22). Consent went back for trial, assuming a class was certified. The opinion is published and binds courts in the Ninth Circuit.
After remand. Judge Gonzalez Rogers denied class certification with prejudice in June 2025, writing that "[i]nquiries relating to Google's implied consent defense will overwhelm the damages claims for all causes of action" (reported by Reuters). The named plaintiffs continued individually, and class counsel report that in June 2026 Wiretap Act, invasion of privacy, CDAFA and declaratory claims survived a motion to dismiss (DiCello Levitt). On 22 September 2026, at the parties' request, the court closed the case administratively until the Ninth Circuit decides Williams v. Capital One Financial Corporation, No. 26-5547 (Dkt. 1149).