Evans v. MH Sub I: SB 690 ends a pending pen-register claim before it takes effect
The plaintiff conceded that California's new SB 690 wiped out his website pen-register claim, months before the law takes effect. The wiretap theory failed too: installing trackers is not the same as reading messages in transit.
- Regulator
- US District Court, Northern District of California
- Law
- CIPA §§ 631(a) and 638.51; federal Wiretap Act; CDAFA; California Constitution; UCL
- Stage
- Ruled. Ruled
The problem
Scott Evans alleged that third-party tracking technologies on the FindLaw website, operated by MH Sub I, LLC (doing business as Internet Brands), collected and disclosed visitors' browsing information. He said he visited the site to research a personal legal issue and then saw more advertising for lawyers and law firms (National Law Review). He sued on behalf of a putative class under CIPA §§ 631(a) and 638.51, the federal Wiretap Act, CDAFA, the California Constitution and the UCL (Order, Dkt. 43).
What the court found
| Claim | Result |
|---|---|
| CIPA § 638.51 (pen register) | Dismissed with prejudice. As Evans agreed, SB 690 removes the private right of action for pen-register claims "alleged to arise from conduct occurring on an internet website, online application, or mobile application". It takes effect 1 January 2027 but applies "retroactively to any pending claim in an action commenced within two years before" that date. This case was filed 20 February 2026 |
| CIPA § 631(a) (aiding and abetting wiretapping) | Dismissed with prejudice. Evans had to allege the trackers read, or tried to read, his communications while in transit; following Doe v. Eating Recovery Center, intercepting in transit is not enough on its own |
| Federal Wiretap Act | Dismissed with prejudice. MH Sub was a party to the communications, and by installing the trackers it consented to their interception |
| CDAFA | Dismissed with prejudice. No "damage or loss" alleged; MH Sub's use of the data to sell advertising does not show harm to Evans |
| UCL | Dismissed with prejudice. No lost money or property; loss of a privacy interest is not economic injury |
| California Constitution, invasion of privacy | Dismissed with leave to amend. The complaint did not say why Evans was researching, what data was collected, how it was used or shared, or what ads followed. The court said interception of identifiable browsing on a legal-research site could be an invasion of privacy |
In a footnote the court warned that even a properly pleaded privacy claim could be hard to certify as a class, because liability could turn on facts about each visitor (Order, Dkt. 43).
Technical issue
- Data (alleged, as summarised from the defence motion): cursor movements, clicks, scrolling, page views, IP addresses, URLs visited, and browser and device information (National Law Review).
- Where: a public legal-research website, where page URLs and searches can reveal a visitor's legal problem.
- Why the claims failed: the court did not decide that the trackers were harmless. The pen-register claim was removed by statute, and the wiretap claims failed on how the interception and the site's own role were pleaded.
Inth's technical interpretation: SB 690 narrows one route for private claims; it does not change what the trackers send. URLs and search terms on a legal, health or financial site can still carry sensitive context, and the constitutional privacy claim survives for now on exactly that point. Keep advertising and session-recording tags behind consent and off pages where the URL or query describes a personal problem.
// Session recorder and ad tags load on every page, including topic pages
loadScript('https://vendor.example/recorder.js');
loadScript('https://ads.example/pixel.js');
// Load only after consent, and never on pages that describe a personal issue
const sensitive = /^\/(legal-topics|search|ask-a-lawyer)/.test(location.pathname);
if (!sensitive && consent.has('marketing')) loadScript('https://ads.example/pixel.js');
if (!sensitive && consent.has('analytics')) loadScript('https://vendor.example/recorder.js');
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 20 February 2026 | Complaint filed in San Mateo County Superior Court |
| 26 March 2026 | MH Sub removes the case to federal court under the Class Action Fairness Act (Dkt. 1) |
| 30 September 2026 | SB 690 signed into law (effective 1 January 2027, retroactive to pending website claims filed within two years before) |
| 6 October 2026 | Evans responds to an order to show cause (Dkt. 42), agreeing SB 690 bars the pen-register claim |
| 20 October 2026 | Motion to dismiss granted (Dkt. 43) |
| 14 days after the order | Deadline for an amended constitutional privacy claim |
Outcome
MH Sub's motion was granted. Every claim except invasion of privacy under the California Constitution was dismissed with prejudice. Evans may file an amended complaint on that claim within 14 days of the 20 October 2026 order (Order, Dkt. 43). No liability has been found and no money has changed hands.
What it cost
| Item | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Damages or settlement | None | Order, Dkt. 43 |
| Defence costs | Not stated in the cited record |
Why it matters
- SB 690 is already ending claims. This is an early federal ruling applying SB 690 to a pending website pen-register claim, before its 1 January 2027 effective date. Expect defendants in other pending § 638.51 cases filed since 1 January 2025 to ask for the same result.
- Wiretap theories still need specifics. Following Doe v. Eating Recovery Center, the court required allegations that the trackers read or tried to read communications in transit, not just that data flowed to them.
- Not a safe harbour. SB 690 does not remove CIPA § 631, regulator enforcement or the constitutional privacy claim, which the court said could succeed on a legal-research site. Compare Asercion v. Ulta.
Related pages: CIPA § 638.51 pen register, CIPA § 631, Federal Wiretap Act, Sensitive context in event data.
How Inth catches this
Consent banner
Holds analytics, session-recording and advertising tags until their category is granted where the policy is opt-in, and applies the visitor's choice before any vendor script loads.
Website audit
Records which vendors receive requests on each page, including URLs, search parameters and identifiers such as IP-derived or device data.
Out of reach
- Inth sees what leaves the browser. It cannot tell whether a vendor read or used the data, which was the question the wiretap claims turned on.
Consent records with choice, country and policy, and per-page runtime observations that show what was sent and when.
Start a free scanChecks for your own systems
Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.
In the repository
0 of 2 doneIn the browser and network
0 of 2 doneWith the people responsible
0 of 2 doneSources and limits
- Order granting motion to dismiss, Dkt. 43, 20 October 2026
- Docket (CourtListener), reviewed 23 October 2026
- National Law Review (Troutman Amin), "SB 690 in action", 22 October 2026
The complaint and the motion to dismiss were not opened. The FindLaw website, the Internet Brands name and the list of data collected come from the National Law Review summary. The order itself does not name the trackers or vendors. Whether Evans has filed an amended complaint was not checked.
Source review: 23 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit MH Sub I's or FindLaw's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.
Facts on record
Each fact is quoted from its source. It says how it was checked and where the source came from.
- Checked by three models
The court granted MH Sub I, LLC's motion to dismiss Evans's first amended complaint, dismissing all claims with prejudice except the invasion-of-privacy claim under the California Constitution, which was dismissed with leave to amend within 14 days.
“Dated: October 20, 2026”
“and now moves to dismiss Evans’s first amended complaint.”
“The motion to dismiss is granted. All claims are dismissed with prejudice, except for Evans’s invasion-of-privacy claim under the California Constitution. That claim is dismissed with leave to amend.”
“Evans may file an amended complaint within 14 days.”
- Checked by three models
Plaintiff Scott Evans brought privacy-related claims on behalf of himself and a putative class against MH Sub I, LLC in state court, filing the action on February 20, 2026.
“Plaintiff Scott Evans brought multiple privacy-related claims on behalf of himself and a putative class against MH Sub I, LLC in state court.”
“This action was filed within that two-year period, on February 20, 2026.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
MH Sub I, LLC removed the case to federal court under the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005.
“MH Sub removed to federal court under the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
MH Sub I, LLC moved to dismiss Evans's first amended complaint.
“now moves to dismiss Evans’s first amended complaint.”