Skip to content

Inth is now agentic by default. Use it from Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor.

See how
Opens the cited record in a new tab

Hickory Farms: an IP address alone did not make a tracking script a pen register

Know which third-party hosts each page calls and what they receive beyond the IP address. In this early Los Angeles pen-register case the complaint never said, and the demurrer was sustained.

Regulator
Los Angeles Superior Court
Law
CIPA
Stage
Tentative: Demurrer sustained with leave to amend. Tentative ruling

The problem

The amended complaint alleged that hickoryfarms.com "secretly installs tracking software on the devices of all visitors" and called it a pen register and a trap-and-trace device (tentative ruling). The court found it described an IP address and little else: not how the data was acquired, by whom, or from which device.

What was alleged

ClaimWhat the law requiresFacts allegedResult
CIPA §638.51No pen register or trap-and-trace device without a court order (§638.51(a))Software installed on visit captured the IP address and routing information; plaintiff described himself as a "tester" (ruling)Demurrer sustained with leave; then dismissed with prejudice
CDAFA §502, CIPA §631, privacy, intrusionVariousPleaded in the original complaint of 25 October 2023Dropped from the amended complaint

Technical issue

  • Tools or vendors: not named in the ruling. The court said the complaint relied on Greenley v. Kochava by "parroting" it.
  • Where: public pages of the retail site.
  • What data: the IP address. The court found nothing showing it equalled the "unique fingerprinting" in Greenley.
  • When: on page load. The court also noted the complaint did not say which device was used.
  • How it came to light: Not stated in the cited record.

Inth's technical interpretation: every request carries the client IP, so any host a page calls learns it. What a third-party script adds is the rest: a cookie ID, user agent, screen size, page URL. Those fields are what the complaint lacked, and they are what an engineer should list per vendor.

// Illustrative pattern, not the defendant's code.
// app/layout.tsx: identity tag loads for every visitor, before any choice
import Script from 'next/script';

export default function RootLayout({ children }) {
  return (
    <html><body>
      {children}
      <Script src="https://tags.identity-vendor.example/v1.js" strategy="afterInteractive" />
    </body></html>
  );
}

Timeline

  1. Complaint filed (docket)

  2. First amended complaint, §638.51 only

  3. Demurrer sustained with 30 days' leave (ruling)

  4. Dismissal with prejudice of the entire action entered at plaintiff's request (docket)

Outcome

Judge Pfahler held the complaint pleaded conclusions, not facts. He agreed that an IP address "may be voluntarily disclosed" by visiting a site, doubted that Hickory Farms was a "third party" to the visitor's communication, and gave a policy reason: reading CIPA to make every visited site a violator "would potentially disrupt a large swath of internet commerce" (ruling). A trial-court ruling binds no other court.

What it cost

ItemRecord
Damages or settlementNot stated in the cited record
Fees or costs awardedNot stated in the cited record
JudgmentNone; voluntary dismissal with prejudice

Why it matters

  • An early Los Angeles ruling against an IP-only pen-register theory. Palacios v. Fandom and Rebeka Rodriguez v. Plivo followed; Rebeka Rodriguez v. Indium Software shows what survived when more was pleaded.
  • In a footnote the court counted at least 19 Los Angeles cases filed under the plaintiff's name with the same firm, and said it remained to be seen whether they would lead to coordination or consolidation.
  • SB 690: Stats. 2026, ch. 976, signed 30 September 2026, operative 1 January 2027 (the default effective date for a 2026 statute). Private §638.51 claims over website and app conduct become Attorney General only, retroactive to pending claims in actions filed on or after 1 January 2025 (bill text). It leaves §631, §632 and §632.7 untouched. This case was filed in 2023 and closed in 2024.
  • See CIPA §638.51 and IP addresses and device identifiers.

How Inth catches this

  • Code audit

    Flags a pull request that adds a third-party identity or ad tag to the site layout, and maps which vendor domain it calls and what it sends.

  • Website audit

    Records each third-party script and destination on production pages, with page, time, region and consent state.

  • Consent banner

    Holds marketing tags until the visitor chooses where the policy is opt-in. Inth's default California policy is opt-out, so tags run before a choice; if pre-consent claims concern you, configure a California opt-in policy.

Out of reach

  • A browser capture shows that a vendor received the request; it cannot show whether the vendor later resolved the IP address to a person.

Runtime observations and finding history show what loaded, where and under which consent state.

Start a free scan

Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

0 of 8 done

In the repository

0 of 3 done

In the browser and network

0 of 3 done

With the people responsible

0 of 2 done

Sources and limits

Source review: 17 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit Hickory Farms' current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.