Why it matters
Shah is the leading federal statement of the website pen register theory. It sits on the opposite side of two Los Angeles lines: trial courts such as Palacios v. Fandom, which Judge Lin addressed in a footnote, and the Court of Appeal's August 2026 tentative in Rose v. Variety Media, which would read the pen register definition to reach only destination-identifying data, so that a visitor's own IP address does not qualify. That tentative is not a decision, and the appeal court is now considering whether SB 690 makes it moot.
Fandom also pleaded that §§ 638.50–638.51 violate the First Amendment, and the Attorney General sought time to intervene (Dkt. 52). The settlement ended the case before the court ruled on that.
SB 690 status: SB 690 (Stats. 2026, ch. 976), signed 30 September 2026, lets only the Attorney General sue a private actor over §638.51 conduct on websites and apps from 1 January 2027 (the default effective date for a 2026 statute). It applies to pending claims in actions filed on or after 1 January 2025, and leaves §631, §632 and §632.7 untouched (bill text). This action was filed in February 2024 and is settled, so SB 690 does not change it, but private suits on this theory end for websites and apps.