Doe v. Amisub (Tenet Healthcare): one pixel settlement for every Tenet hospital website and portal
Tenet settled tracking claims from five courts in one Tennessee case. The class is defined by three actions: creating a portal account, submitting a web form, or checking in to urgent care or the ER online. Those are the pages where advertising and analytics tags do the most damage.
- Proposed amount
- USD8,500,000
- Regulator
- Circuit Court for Shelby County, Tennessee
- Law
- Health-data tracking and privacy claims
- Stage
- Settlement preliminarily approved 22 September 2026; final approval hearing 14 January 2027. Preliminary approval
The problem
The action was filed on 28 July 2023 against Saint Francis Hospital-Memphis, a Tenet hospital. Its website links to a patient portal on a third-party domain, where patients search for doctors, schedule appointments, check in to emergency rooms, schedule telehealth and pay bills. Plaintiffs alleged that Saint Francis and the other Tenet affiliated covered entities disclosed patients' personally identifiable information and protected health information to third parties, including Meta, Google, Marketo, Invoca and Healthgrades, through website tracking technologies (Settlement Agreement, recitals C to F). Tenet denies any wrongdoing.
What the settlement covers
| Issue | Term |
|---|---|
| Class | Identifiable individuals who used a Tenet website or patient portal to create a portal account, submit a web form, or check in to urgent care or an emergency room |
| Class period | 1 January 2017 to 18 September 2023 |
| Class size | About 1,200,000 people, per the preliminary approval order |
| Platforms | Tenet websites, patient portals, the HealtheLife app and other web-based tools |
| Related cases | Suits in the Eastern and Central Districts of California, Orange County Superior Court, the District of Massachusetts and Dallas County District Court, consolidated into this action through a stipulated amended complaint |
| Released technologies | Including Meta Pixel, Google Analytics, Google Ads, Adobe, Marketo, Tealium, Heap Analytics, Siteimprove, Invoca and Healthgrades |
Sources: Preliminary approval order; Settlement Agreement; Notice.
Technical issue
- Where the data came from: hospital websites and patient portals, including account creation, web forms, and urgent care or ER check-in.
- Who received it (alleged): Meta, Google, Marketo, Invoca, Healthgrades and likely others.
- Why it is sensitive: plaintiffs say the hospitals are HIPAA covered entities and some of the data is protected health information.
Inth's technical interpretation: treat forms, check-in flows and every page that links into the portal as sensitive. Advertising and marketing-automation tags should not load there at all. Analytics on those pages should drop query strings, form fields and anything that identifies the condition, doctor or visit.
// Marketing tags load site-wide, including check-in and portal sign-up
loadTag('ads-pixel');
loadTag('marketing-automation');
// Sensitive routes never load marketing tags
const sensitive = ['/check-in', '/patient-portal', '/forms'];
if (!sensitive.some(p => location.pathname.startsWith(p)) && consent.has('marketing')) {
loadTag('ads-pixel');
}
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 28 July 2023 | Complaint filed against Saint Francis Hospital-Memphis in Shelby County Circuit Court |
| 1 November 2023 | Amended complaint filed |
| 30 July 2026 | Settlement Agreement signed by Tenet and class counsel |
| 22 September 2026 | Preliminary approval order entered (Judge Gina Higgins) |
| 22 October 2026 | Notice mailing date, per the settlement website |
| 21 December 2026 | Deadline to opt out or object |
| 14 January 2027 | Final approval hearing, 10:00 a.m. Central Time |
| 15 March 2027 | Claim deadline |
Outcome
The settlement is not final. The court preliminarily approved it and conditionally certified a settlement class on 22 September 2026, and will decide on final approval, fees and service awards at a hearing on 14 January 2027 (Preliminary approval order; Notice). Benefits are paid only after final approval and any appeals.
What it cost
| Item | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Cash payment per claiming class member | $16, no proof required | Notice |
| Privacy protection | Two years of CyEx Privacy Shield Pro for every class member | Notice |
| Attorneys' fees and costs requested | Up to $8,500,000, paid by Tenet | Preliminary approval order |
| Service awards requested | $3,500 for each of 28 class representatives | Notice |
| Total settlement fund | Not stated in the documents reviewed | Settlement website |
Why it matters
- One case can sweep in a whole hospital system. Five related suits in other courts were folded into a single state-court settlement covering every Tenet affiliated covered entity.
- The class is defined by sensitive actions. Portal sign-up, web forms and ER or urgent care check-in are named, not general browsing.
- Marketing tools count, not only ad pixels. The release lists marketing automation, call tracking, tag managers and session analytics alongside Meta and Google. Compare Cone Health, Allina Health and Novant Health.
How Inth catches this
Consent banner
Holds advertising and marketing purposes behind consent and can keep them off check-in, form and portal routes entirely.
Website audit
Loads public pages in a clean profile and records third-party requests on forms and portal entry points before and after a choice.
Out of reach
- Inth cannot see inside a logged-in patient portal hosted on a third-party domain.
Consent records with choice, purpose, country and policy version.
Start a free scanChecks for your own systems
Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.
In the repository
0 of 2 doneIn the browser and network
0 of 2 doneWith the people responsible
0 of 2 doneSources and limits
- Preliminary approval order, file-stamped 22 September 2026
- Class Action Settlement Agreement, signed 30 July 2026
- Long-form notice and settlement website
- ClassAction.org, 29 October 2026
The preliminary approval order, the settlement agreement (recitals, definitions and signature pages), the long-form notice and the settlement website were opened. The agreement's signature pages are scanned images; the 30 July 2026 date comes from the class counsel e-signature stamp. The complaints and the stipulated amended complaint were not opened, so specific legal claims are not listed. No total fund is stated. No typed jurisdiction: the archive has no "tennessee" facet, so jurisdiction is omitted and publishing will need one added.
Source review: 31 October 2026. This page describes the cited record and procedural stage. It does not audit the company's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.
Facts on record
Each fact is quoted from its source. It says how it was checked and where the source came from. 1 of 10 is carried over from the old enforcement tracker and not yet checked against its source.
- Unchecked
Plaintiffs alleged Tenet Healthcare's Saint Francis Hospital-Memphis and other affiliated hospitals disclosed patients' personal and health information to Meta, Google, Marketo, Invoca, Healthgrades and others through tracking technologies on their websites and patient portals. Related suits in four other courts were folded into one Tennessee state-court settlement.
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court ordered that, pending final determination of whether the Settlement Agreement should be approved, Plaintiffs and Settlement Class Members are barred and enjoined from commencing or prosecuting any claims asserting Released Claims against Defendant or any Affiliated Covered Entities.
“13. Pending final determination of whether the Settlement Agreement should be approved, Plaintiffs and Settlement Class Members are barred and enjoined from commencing or prosecuting any claims asserting any of the Released Claims against Defendant or any Affiliated Covered Entities.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs filed an Unopposed Motion for Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement with the Court.
“Before this Court is Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion for Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement (“Motion”).”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court granted Plaintiffs' motion and preliminarily concluded that the proposed Settlement Agreement is within the range of fair, reasonable, and adequate, and ordered the Settlement Administrator to provide Notice to the Class.
“this Court grants the Motion and preliminarily concludes that the proposed Settlement Agreement is with the range of fair, reasonable, and adequate, and orders the Settlement Administrator to provide Notice to the Class under the terms of the Settlement Agreement and this Order.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court preliminarily and conditionally certified the Settlement Class for settlement purposes only, appointed the named Plaintiffs as Settlement Class Representatives, appointed J. Gerard Stranch, IV of Stranch, Jennings & Garvey, PLLC as Class Counsel, and appointed Simpluris, Inc. as the Settlement Administrator.
“4. The Court appoints Plaintiffs Melissa Alvarez, Karen Beauregard, Lori Woolhouse, Cory Burns, Colleen Burns, George Demiter, Blake Busson, Sidney Cauthen, Heather DeLano, Patricia Flores, Jacqueline Hillie, Michael L. Johnson, Sr., Romanda Williams Johnson, Jennifer Mathis, Robert Oldham, Tiffany Rodriguez, Jonathan Schmid, Latonya Williams, Barbara-Ann Klickstein, Nancy Zide, Lisa Danforth, Tammy Newman, Victoria Randolph, Michael Johnson, Lori Beltran, Brittany Matus, Mark Mehring, and Judith Harrill as the Settlement Class Representatives.”
“2. The Court hereby preliminarily and conditionally approves and certifies, for settlement purposes only, the following Settlement Class:”
“6. The Court appoints Simpluris, Inc. as the Settlement Administrator.”
“5. The Court appoints J. Gerard Stranch, IV of Stranch, Jennings & Garvey, PLLC as Class Counsel.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court approved the form and content of the Notice plan set forth in the Settlement Agreement and preliminarily approved the Settlement Timeline.
“8. The Court approves, as to the form and content, the Notice plan as set forth in the Settlement Agreement.”
“The Court preliminarily approves the following Settlement Timeline for the purposes of conducting the notice plan, settlement administration, claims processing, and other execution of the proposed Settlement Agreement:”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court set a Final Approval Hearing for January 14, 2027 at 10:00 am to determine, among other things, whether the proposed Settlement Agreement is fair, reasonable, and adequate and should be approved.
“b) To determine whether the proposed Settlement Agreement is fair, reasonable, and adequate to the Settlement Class and should be approved by the Court;”
“a) To determine whether all the requirements of Tennessee Rule 23 have been met,”
“7. A Final Approval Hearing shall be held before the Court January 14, 2027 at 10:00 am for the following purposes:”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court appointed J. Gerard Stranch, IV of Stranch, Jennings & Garvey, PLLC as Class Counsel to represent the Class Members.
“you and other Class Members (“Class Counsel”).”
“Yes, the Court has appointed attorney J. Gerard Stranch, IV of Stranch, Jennings & Garvey, PLLC, to represent”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Notice states that the Court will hold a final approval hearing, on a date not yet filled in, to decide whether to approve the Settlement, how Class Counsel should be paid, and whether to award Service Award payments.
“At the final approval hearing, the Court will decide whether to approve the Settlement. The court will also”
“The Court will hold a final approval on [FA Hearing Date] at [Hearing Time] Central Time, in Room [Court”
“decide how Class Counsel should be paid, and whether to award Service Award payments to the Class”
- Date not statedUS$8,500,000Checked by three models
The Notice states that Class Counsel will ask the Court to approve $8,500,000.00 in attorney's fees and litigation costs, to be paid by Tenet Healthcare, and Service Award payments of $3,500.00 for each Class Representative.
“Class Counsel will ask the court to approve $8,500,000.00 as reasonable attorney's fees and reimbursement”
“Class Counsel will also ask for Service Award payments of $3,500.00 for each of the Class Representatives.”
“of litigation costs. This amount will be paid by Tenet Healthcare.”