Rand v. Eyemart Express: Fifth Circuit revives Meta Pixel claims over eyewear shopping and eye-exam bookings
A federal appeals court said browsing for prescription glasses and booking an eye exam can be health information when a Pixel pairs it with a Facebook identity. The court said it knew of no earlier circuit decision on Pixel tracking of health data.
- Regulator
- US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
- Law
- Federal Wiretap Act; Missouri Wiretap Act; Illinois Eavesdropping Act; intrusion upon seclusion; breach of contract (HIPAA definition of IIHI used as a guide)
- Stage
- Ruled. Ruled
The problem
Eyemart Express runs eyewear stores and a website where people browse products, buy prescription eyewear and schedule eye exams. Five Facebook users alleged that the Meta Pixel on the site tracked their searches, clicks, product views and appointment scheduling and gave that data to Meta, without notice or consent. Meta could combine it with their Facebook profiles to identify them and target ads (Opinion, pp. 2 to 3). They also alleged that Eyemart uploads customer lists to Meta with email addresses and the prescription eyewear people bought or viewed, so Meta can match them to Facebook profiles (Opinion, p. 17).
What the court found
| Question | Holding |
|---|---|
| Standing | Plaintiffs have Article III standing. Unauthorised disclosure of private browsing activity with identifiable information is a concrete injury, following Salazar v. Paramount, Pileggi, Salazar v. NBA and In re BPS Direct |
| Search Plaintiffs (browsed and searched for prescription glasses; one booked an eye exam) | The district court erred. Shopping and scheduling information "relates to" health and the provision of health care within HIPAA's IIHI definition, 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6). Eyemart's counsel conceded at argument that what Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable |
| Prescription Plaintiffs (entered prescriptions to buy eyewear) | The district court erred in finding no IIHI reached Meta. It relied on one example screenshot (an AddToCart event) and drew inferences for Eyemart, instead of reading the complaint as a whole |
| Merits | Not decided. The district court must reconsider every substantive claim; HIPAA-based arguments in the Wiretap Act claim were left open |
The court noted that "without the benefit of discovery, Plaintiffs cannot be expected to know much more at this early stage" (Opinion, p. 17).
Technical issue
- Data (alleged): searches, clicks, product views including make, model, materials and product IDs of frames and lenses, prescription eyewear purchases, and eye-exam scheduling details including the store's name and location.
- Recipient: Meta, through the Pixel, combined with Facebook account data; plus customer-list uploads with email addresses and purchase information.
- Where: product pages for prescription items, cart and checkout, and appointment booking.
Inth's technical interpretation: the court rejected the idea that only a literal prescription counts. Product names, URLs and booking events on a vision or health site can carry health context on their own once a pixel ties them to an identity. Treat these pages as sensitive: keep advertising pixels off them, or strip event parameters to what is strictly needed, and keep all of it behind consent.
// Ad pixel fires on every page, including prescription products and exam booking
fbq('track', 'AddToCart', { content_ids: [sku], content_name: productName });
// Gate on consent and keep health-context pages out of ad events
const healthPage = /^\/(prescription|lenses|book-exam|appointments)/.test(location.pathname);
if (consent.has('marketing') && !healthPage) {
fbq('track', 'AddToCart', { value: price, currency: 'USD' });
}
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2024 | Putative class action filed in N.D. Texas (No. 3:24-CV-621) |
| Not stated in the opinion | First motion to dismiss: standing found, claims dismissed with leave to amend |
| Not stated in the opinion | Second motion to dismiss granted in full; case dismissed with prejudice |
| 2025 | Appeal docketed (No. 25-10784) |
| 23 October 2026 | Fifth Circuit reverses and remands |
Outcome
The Fifth Circuit agreed the plaintiffs have standing, reversed the dismissal on the grounds that the Search Plaintiffs shared no IIHI with Eyemart and that no plaintiff's IIHI reached Meta, and remanded for further proceedings (Opinion, p. 18). The district court will now decide whether each claim's elements are pleaded. No liability has been found and no money has changed hands.
What it cost
| Item | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Damages or settlement | None | Opinion |
| Defence costs | Not stated in the cited record |
Why it matters
- First circuit ruling on Pixel tracking of health data. The court said neither side cited, and it was not aware of, any earlier circuit decision on the question.
- Health context is broader than a diagnosis. Browsing and booking on a vision-care site was enough at the pleading stage, distinguishing the narrower IP-address-plus-visit data in the Becerra case and following Cousin v. Sharp Healthcare.
- Example screenshots are not the whole complaint. A district court cannot dismiss because one illustrative network capture fails to show a prescription.
Related pages: Federal Wiretap Act, Article III standing, Sensitive context in event data, Undisclosed data exchanges.
How Inth catches this
Consent banner
Holds advertising pixels until marketing consent is granted where the policy is opt-in, and applies the visitor's choice before any vendor script loads.
Website audit
Records which vendors receive requests on product, cart and booking pages, and which event parameters and URLs they carry.
Out of reach
- Inth sees what leaves the browser. It cannot see server-side customer-list uploads, which were also alleged here.
Consent records with choice, country and policy, and per-page runtime observations that show what was sent and when.
Start a free scanChecks for your own systems
Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.
In the repository
0 of 2 doneIn the browser and network
0 of 2 doneWith the people responsible
0 of 2 doneSources and limits
- Fifth Circuit opinion, No. 25-10784, filed 23 October 2026
- Recording Law news summary
The complaint, the district court orders and the appeal docket were not opened, so the district judge and the dates of the two dismissal orders are not given. Facts about the Pixel come from the plaintiffs' allegations as the opinion describes them. Whether rehearing has been sought or the mandate has issued was not checked.
The library has no Texas jurisdiction value; this page is filed under US federal as an appellate ruling.
Source review: 24 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit Eyemart's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.
Facts on record
Each fact is quoted from its source. It says how it was checked and where the source came from.
- Checked by a person
The Fifth Circuit read HIPAA's definition of individually identifiable health information (IIHI) in 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6) as not requiring disclosure of a specific diagnosis or condition, so information that pertains to a condition or the provision of healthcare is sufficient.
“October 23, 2026”
“Again, IIHI covers information “collected from an individual” that “relates to” an individual’s “past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition,” “the provision of health care to an individual,” or “the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care.” 42 U.S.C. § 1320d(6) (emphasis added). It need not reveal a specific diagnosis or condition; that it pertains to a condition or provision of healthcare is sufficient.”
“More specifically, Plaintiffs allege that this information meets the definition of individually identifiable health information (“IIHI”) protected under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (“HIPAA”)”
- Checked by three models
The Fifth Circuit held that Plaintiffs have Article III standing, reversed the district court's dismissal on the grounds that the Search Plaintiffs had not shared IIHI with Eyemart and that no Plaintiffs' IIHI was shared with Meta, and remanded for further proceedings.
“In accordance with the foregoing, we agree with the district court that Plaintiffs have standing, and REVERSE the district court’s dismissal on the grounds that the Search Plaintiffs had not shared IIHI with Eyemart and that neither the Search Plaintiffs nor the Prescription Plaintiffs’ IIHI was shared with Meta and REMAND for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.”
“FILED October 23, 2026”
“Accordingly, Plaintiffs have Article III standing, and we turn to the merits.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs, five Facebook users who used Eyemart's website (the Site), brought suit under the Federal Wiretap Act, the Missouri Wiretap Act and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, with intrusion upon seclusion and breach of contract claims, contending that information the Pixel tracked from the Site is private health information that Eyemart should not have permitted Meta to access without their knowledge or consent.
“Eyemart owns and operates a chain of physical stores as well as a website (“the Site”)”
“They contend that the information the Pixel tracked from the Site—related to viewing and purchasing prescription eyeglasses and scheduling eye exams—is private health information that Eyemart should not have permitted Meta to access without Plaintiffs’ knowledge or consent.”
“Plaintiffs are five Facebook users who used the Site. They brought suit under the Federal Wiretap Act, the Missouri Wiretap Act, and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, in addition to an intrusion upon seclusion tort claim and breach of contract claims.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The district court granted Eyemart's second motion to dismiss in full and dismissed the case with prejudice, finding that the Search Plaintiffs did not adequately allege that they shared any IIHI with Eyemart and that the Prescription Plaintiffs failed to show IIHI was disclosed to Meta.
“Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim but did not renew its standing arguments.”
“As to the Prescription Plaintiffs, the district court acknowledged that they shared IIHI with Eyemart by entering their prescription information but found that they had failed to show that any IIHI was disclosed to Meta.”
“allege that they shared any IIHI with Eyemart”
“The district court granted the second motion to dismiss in full and dismissed the case with prejudice. The district court found that the Search Plaintiffs failed to state a claim for relief because they did not adequately”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Eyemart filed a first motion to dismiss, asserting that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.
“In the first motion to dismiss, Eyemart asserted that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
On Eyemart's first motion to dismiss, the district court determined that Plaintiffs had standing but had failed to state a claim, and afforded Plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their complaint.
“In the first motion to dismiss, Eyemart asserted that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.”
“The district court determined that Plaintiffs had standing but had failed to state a claim and afforded Plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their complaint.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
After Plaintiffs filed the Amended Complaint, Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim without renewing its standing arguments.
“Plaintiffs then filed the operative complaint (“the Amended Complaint”). Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim but did not renew its standing arguments.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs appealed the district court's dismissal to the Fifth Circuit, asking it to reverse, reinstate all of their claims, and remand.
“Plaintiffs ask us to reverse, reinstate all of their claims, and remand.”
“This is an appeal from the dismissal of a putative class action concerning the alleged unauthorized disclosure of Plaintiffs’ private health information from Defendant Eyemart Express, LLC (“Eyemart”) to third party Meta Platforms, Inc. (“Meta”).”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Fifth Circuit heard oral argument, at which Eyemart's counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable.
“At oral argument, Eyemart’s counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable because, through Facebook, the information was linked to specific users.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs, five Facebook users who used Eyemart's Site, brought suit against Eyemart under the Federal Wiretap Act, the Missouri Wiretap Act and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, with intrusion upon seclusion and breach of contract claims, contending that information the Pixel tracked from the Site is private health information Eyemart should not have permitted Meta to access without their knowledge or consent.
“They contend that the information the Pixel tracked from the Site—related to viewing and purchasing prescription eyeglasses and scheduling eye exams—is private health information that Eyemart should not have permitted Meta to access without Plaintiffs’ knowledge or consent.”
“Plaintiffs are five Facebook users who used the Site. They brought suit under the Federal Wiretap Act, the Missouri Wiretap Act, and the Illinois Eavesdropping Act, in addition to an intrusion upon seclusion tort claim and breach of contract claims.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Eyemart filed a first motion to dismiss in the district court, asserting that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.
“The district court considered two motions to dismiss in this case. In the first motion to dismiss, Eyemart asserted that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
On Eyemart's first motion to dismiss, the district court determined that Plaintiffs had standing but had failed to state a claim, and afforded Plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their complaint.
“The district court determined that Plaintiffs had standing but had failed to state a claim and afforded Plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their complaint.”
“In the first motion to dismiss, Eyemart asserted that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
After Plaintiffs filed the Amended Complaint, Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim without renewing its standing arguments.
“Plaintiffs then filed the operative complaint (“the Amended Complaint”). Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim but did not renew its standing arguments.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The district court granted Eyemart's second motion to dismiss in full and dismissed the case with prejudice, finding that the Search Plaintiffs did not adequately allege sharing IIHI with Eyemart and that the Prescription Plaintiffs failed to show any IIHI was disclosed to Meta.
“The district court found that the Search Plaintiffs failed to state a claim for relief because they did not adequately”
“Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim but did not renew its standing arguments.”
“allege that they shared any IIHI with Eyemart.3 As to the Prescription Plaintiffs, the district court acknowledged that they shared IIHI with Eyemart by entering their prescription information but found that they had failed to show that any IIHI was disclosed to Meta.”
“The district court granted the second motion to dismiss in full and dismissed the case with prejudice.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs appealed the district court's dismissal to the Fifth Circuit, asking it to reverse, reinstate all of their claims and remand.
“Plaintiffs ask us to reverse, reinstate all of their claims, and remand.”
“This is an appeal from the dismissal of a putative class action”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Fifth Circuit heard oral argument, at which Eyemart's counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable.
“At oral argument, Eyemart’s counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable because, through Facebook, the information was linked to specific users.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Eyemart filed a first motion to dismiss, asserting that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.
“In the first motion to dismiss, Eyemart asserted that Plaintiffs lacked standing and failed to state a claim.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim, without renewing its standing arguments.
“Eyemart again moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim but did not renew its standing arguments.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Plaintiffs appealed the dismissal from the Northern District of Texas to the Fifth Circuit.
“This is an appeal from the dismissal of a putative class action”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Fifth Circuit heard oral argument, at which Eyemart's counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable.
“At oral argument, Eyemart’s counsel conceded that the information Meta received through the Pixel was individually identifiable”