Skip to content

Inth is now agentic by default. Use it from Claude, ChatGPT or Cursor.

See how
Opens the cited record in a new tab

Novant Health: a pixel's automatic events can read what patients click

A Meta Pixel does more than count page views. With automatic events on, it reports the text of buttons people click. Novant Health's MyChart portal was where reporters showed that, and the class action that followed settled for USD 6.66 million. If a pixel must run, switch off what you did not ask it to collect, and keep it off logged-in pages.

Settlement
USD6,660,000
Regulator
US District Court, Middle District of North Carolina
Law
Privacy and related civil claims
Stage
Settlement approval and distribution order dated 17 June 2024. Court order

The problem

Patients alleged that "Novant willfully shared the plaintiffs' personally identifiable information and personal health information with the company Facebook" through the Facebook Pixel, which "allowed the plaintiffs' personal and health-related information as well as website activity to be sent to Facebook without the plaintiffs' consent" (Doc. 67 at 1–2, summarizing the amended complaint). Novant denies wrongdoing.

What was alleged

The first complaint was filed on 23 August 2022; similar suits were consolidated in October 2022, and an amended complaint with nine counts followed in November 2022 (Doc. 67 at 1–2).

ClaimWhat the law requiresFacts allegedResult
Federal claimsNot described in Doc. 67Novant used the Facebook Pixel to monitor activity on its platformDismissed on 24 August 2023 (Doc. 44); plaintiffs kept the option to appeal (Doc. 67 at 2, 14)
Breach of fiduciary dutyA provider's duty of confidentiality to its patientsPatient information went to Facebook without consentSurvived the motion to dismiss; settled
Breach of implied contractPromises implied from the provider relationshipPatients gave data expecting confidentialitySurvived the motion to dismiss; settled
Other state-law countsVariousSame conductDismissed

The court called the law on "the surreptitious sharing of user data" still developing, which made the likelihood of success at trial hard to judge (Doc. 67 at 13–14).

Technical issue

  • Tools or vendors: the Meta (Facebook) Pixel (Doc. 67 at 2).
  • Where: Novant's websites and its MyChart patient portal. The class covers people whose information may have been disclosed "because of the defendant's use of tracking tools on the defendant's websites or MyChart patient portal" (Doc. 67 at 5).
  • What data: The Markup reported that in Novant's MyChart the pixel told Facebook "the type of allergic reaction the patient had to a specific medication", "the name and dosage of a medication in our health record, as well as any notes we had entered about the prescription", and "which button we clicked in response to a question about sexual orientation" (The Markup, 16 June 2022).
  • When: the class period runs from 1 May 2020 to 12 August 2022 (Doc. 67 at 5). No consent step was alleged.
  • How it came to light: The Markup's Pixel Hunt, run with Mozilla Rally volunteers. A Novant spokesperson told The Markup that "Our Meta pixel placement is guided by a third party vendor and it has been removed while we continue to look into this matter" (same).

Inth's technical interpretation: the payloads The Markup published ("tag":"a", "numChildButtons":0, button text) are what the Meta Pixel's automatic SubscribedButtonClick event sends. Automatic events are on by default. They serialize the text and attributes of whatever element a visitor clicks, so a pixel placed for a marketing campaign starts collecting whatever the portal renders inside buttons and links: medication names, appointment details, survey answers. Nobody has to write a single custom event for this to happen.

Illustrative pattern, not the defendant's code.
<!-- Portal page template: base pixel only, automatic events left on -->
<script>
  !function(f,b,e,v,n,t,s){/* Meta Pixel base code */}(window, document,'script',
  'https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js');
  fbq('init', '123456789012345');
  fbq('track', 'PageView');
  // Clicking <button>Amoxicillin 500 mg: rash</button> now sends
  // ev=SubscribedButtonClick with the button text in cd[buttonFeatures]
</script>

Timeline

  1. The Markup publishes its Pixel Hunt findings, including Novant's MyChart (The Markup)

  2. Kevin and Christine Curry file the first complaint (Doc. 67 at 1)

  3. Amended complaint with nine counts (Doc. 67 at 2)

  4. Parties agree a settlement in principle (Doc. 67 at 3)

  5. Motion to dismiss granted except two state claims, Doc. 44 (Doc. 67 at 2)

  6. Preliminary approval (Doc. 67 at 3)

  7. Claim deadline; claims processed to 6 May 2024 (Doc. 67 at 4 n.5)

  8. Final approval hearing (Doc. 67 at 1)

  9. Memorandum opinion, order and judgment (Doc. 67)

Outcome

  • Fund: USD 6,660,000, non-reversionary; Novant's insurer deposited the full amount (Doc. 67 at 15).
  • Fees: USD 2,220,000, one-third of the fund, after a lodestar cross-check (counsel reported about 1,600 hours at the fee motion); expenses USD 18,134.70 (Doc. 67 at 22, 28).
  • Per person: pro rata share of the net fund to each valid claimant. The per-claimant amount is not stated in the cited record.
  • Class: 1,361,159 identified class members; notice reached 1,349,789 (99.2%); 159,881 valid, timely claims (about 11.7%); 37 opt-outs and no objections (Doc. 67 at 4, 15).
  • Practice changes: none described in the cited order.
  • Not established: no liability finding.

What it cost

ItemAmountSource
Settlement fundUSD 6,660,000 (insurer-funded)Doc. 67 at 15
Attorneys' feesUSD 2,220,000 (33.3%)Doc. 67 at 28
ExpensesUSD 18,134.70same
Service awardsUSD 25,000 (10 × USD 2,500)Doc. 67 at 26, 28
AdministrationAbout USD 602,000 estimated (USD 164,000 under the original forecast, helped by email notice and digital payments)Doc. 67 at 26–27
Defense costsNot stated in the cited record

Why it matters

  • Federal claims failed, state claims paid. The federal counts were dismissed, yet breach of confidence and implied contract carried a USD 6.66 million settlement. Dropping a wiretap theory does not end a health-tracking case.
  • Reporting, then litigation. The Markup's June 2022 reporting preceded the first complaint by two months. Journalists and researchers can capture the same payloads a plaintiff's expert would.
  • Insurance. The fund was paid by Novant's insurer, a reminder that cyber and privacy policies are now part of how these cases close.

Related law and issue pages: Federal Wiretap Act (for comparison), Sensitive context in event data.

How Inth catches this

  • Code audit

    Flags a pull request that adds the Meta Pixel base code to a template the portal uses, and flags pixels initialized without autoConfig disabled where buttons render health data.

  • Website audit

    Records facebook.com/tr requests from portal pages, including SubscribedButtonClick events, with the page, time, region and consent state.

  • Consent banner

    Holds the Meta Pixel until the marketing category is granted where the policy is opt-in. Consent on a public page does not make portal collection acceptable.

Out of reach

  • Website audit sees the pages it observes; what Meta did with the events after receipt is outside any browser check.

Dated runtime observations per page and the finding history for the template change.

Start a free scan

Checks for your own systems

Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.

0 of 7 done

In the repository

0 of 3 done

In the browser and network

0 of 2 done

With the people responsible

0 of 2 done

Sources and limits

Source review: 17 October 2026. This page describes the cited records and procedural stage. It does not audit Novant Health's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.