In re Google Cloud Contact Center AI: Home Depot callers' CIPA claims dismissed over consent and intent
A privacy statement that says call recordings go to service providers covered the AI vendor that listened in, for callers who had agreed to it. For a caller who had not, the claim still failed because nothing showed Google meant to listen without consent.
- Regulator
- US District Court, Northern District of California
- Law
- CIPA § 631(a)
- Stage
- Ruled. Ruled
The problem
When a consumer calls a company that uses Google Cloud Contact Center AI, such as Home Depot, a Google "virtual agent" answers first without saying it is provided by Google. If the caller asks for a person, the call passes to the company's agent, and the plaintiffs alleged that Google keeps listening, giving the agent a real-time transcript, suggested articles and "smart replies", and can use the recordings to improve its own AI models (Order, pp. 1 to 2). The remaining named plaintiffs, James Fox, Peter Samish and Christopher Barulich, all called Home Depot and claimed one count under CIPA § 631(a).
What the court found
| Question | Holding |
|---|---|
| Is consent an element or a defence? | An element the plaintiff must plead. The court followed Atkins v. Amplitude, Perry-Hudson v. Twilio and Smith v. YETI, and read Calhoun v. Google as not deciding the point |
| Accountholders (Fox and Samish) | No plausible lack of consent. Home Depot's account terms incorporated a privacy statement disclosing that customer-care call recordings go to "service providers that process information on [Home Depot's] behalf", which plainly covers Google. Real-time sharing and Google not being named did not take it outside that consent |
| Use for Google's own models | Not a § 631(a)(3) claim on its own: use is unlawful only if the information came from a violation of clauses (1) or (2), and Google had consent to listen |
| Non-accountholder (Barulich) | Lack of consent plausibly pleaded. Google did not show he saw or agreed to the privacy statement, and calls commonly being recorded does not establish consent to an unannounced third party |
| Intent (all three) | Not pleaded. § 631(a) requires that Google intended to listen without consent; the complaint only repeated the statutory words. Google's contract requiring Home Depot to obtain consent is relevant but does not end the case as a matter of law |
The court said it "seems unlikely" Fox and Samish could bring claims given the privacy statement, but allowed amendment (Order, p. 6).
Technical issue
- Data (alleged): the audio and content of customer-service calls, live transcripts and call context used to suggest replies.
- Recipient: Google, as the provider of the contact-centre AI, with the alleged capability to use recordings to improve its own models.
- Where: the phone line, not a website; the consent analysis turned on the company's account terms and privacy statement.
Inth's technical interpretation: this is the same question as a chat widget or session-replay vendor on a website. A disclosure that names the category of recipient (service providers) protected the vendor for people who had agreed to it. It did nothing for a caller with no account, whose claim failed only on intent. Vendor contracts that make the customer responsible for consent matter, but the court would not treat them as a complete answer.
// Live-chat or voice assistant loads a third-party AI vendor before any notice
loadVendorWidget('ai-agent');
// Show who is listening and record that the notice was shown first
showNotice('This conversation is handled with our AI service provider and may be recorded.');
consent.record({ purpose: 'support-ai', noticeVersion: 'v3' });
loadVendorWidget('ai-agent');
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 23 October 2023 | Misael Ambriz files the first suit (per a MassArbitration summary; not checked against the docket) |
| Not stated in the order | Cases consolidated; operative complaint Dkt. 112 |
| 22 October 2026 | Order compelling several plaintiffs to arbitration (Dkt. 140) and order granting Google's motion to dismiss the Home Depot callers (Dkt. 141) |
| 12 November 2026 | Deadline for an amended complaint. An amended complaint was filed that day (Dkt. 142, per the court's docket feed as shown by CaseMagic); its contents were not reviewed |
Outcome
Google's motion to dismiss was granted and the claims of Fox, Samish and Barulich were dismissed with leave to amend. They may not add new claims or parties without leave or a stipulation (Order, pp. 8 to 9). An amended complaint was filed on the 12 November 2026 deadline (Dkt. 142, docket feed via CaseMagic), so the case continues. Which plaintiffs it names and what it alleges were not reviewed. No liability has been found and no money has changed hands.
What it cost
| Item | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Damages or settlement | None | Order |
| Defence costs | Not stated in the cited record |
Why it matters
- Category disclosures can cover AI vendors. "Service providers" in an accepted privacy statement was enough for real-time AI listening by Google, at least at the pleading stage.
- People who never accepted the terms are different. Account holders and non-account callers got different consent results from the same call flow.
- Intent now has to be pleaded with facts. Plaintiffs must allege something showing the vendor knew consent was missing, not just repeat the statute.
Related pages: CIPA § 631 wiretapping, Session replay and chat recording, Notice, consent scope and assent.
How Inth catches this
Consent banner
Shows notice and records consent before chat, voice or session-recording vendors load on your pages, so assent exists for visitors who never created an account.
Website audit
Records which third parties receive chat transcripts, recordings or form content from each page, before and after a choice.
Out of reach
- Phone lines and contact-centre platforms are outside what a website audit sees. Review them with the teams that run them.
Consent records with choice, notice and policy version and time, which is the kind of record that decided the accountholders' claims here.
Start a free scanChecks for your own systems
Your ticks stay on this page. Inth does not save or send them.
In the repository
0 of 2 doneIn the browser and network
0 of 2 doneWith the people responsible
0 of 2 doneSources and limits
- Order granting motion to dismiss, Dkt. 141, filed 22 October 2026
- MassArbitration summary
- CaseMagic docket feed, showing Dkt. 142 Amended Complaint filed 12 November 2026
The arbitration order (Dkt. 140), the complaint and the docket were not opened, so which plaintiffs and which companies' calls went to arbitration are not stated here. Facts about the product come from the plaintiffs' allegations as the order describes them. The 2023 filing date comes from a secondary summary. The amended complaint (Dkt. 142) was not opened; only its filing is confirmed from the court's docket feed.
Source review: 13 November 2026. This page describes the cited record and procedural stage. It does not audit Google's or Home Depot's current systems. Inth wrote the technical checks; they cannot decide which laws apply or prove compliance.
Facts on record
Each fact is quoted from its source. It says how it was checked and where the source came from.
- Checked by three models
The court granted Google's motion to dismiss and dismissed the claims of Fox, Samish, and Barulich under Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act with leave to amend, setting November 12, 2026 as the deadline to file an amended complaint, failing which the claims will remain dismissed with prejudice.
“For the reasons explained above, Google’s Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED. Fox, Samish, and Barulich’s claims are DISMISSED with LEAVE TO AMEND.”
“If they wish to file an amended complaint correcting the deficiencies identified above, they shall do so by November 12, 2026. They may not add new claims or parties without leave of the Court or stipulation by the parties pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15. If no such amended Case 3:23-cv-05437-RFL Document 141 Filed 10/22/26 Page 8 of 9 PageID #: 1947 9 complaint is filed by that date, their claims will remain dismissed with prejudice.”
“Dated: October 22, 2026”
“Google moves to dismiss the remaining named plaintiffs, who allege Google recorded their customer service calls with non-party Home Depot, in violation of Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act.”
- Checked by three models
The court granted Google's unopposed request for judicial notice as to the documents concerning Home Depot and denied it as moot as to all other documents.
“Google’s unopposed request for judicial notice (Dkt. No. 122) is granted as to the documents concerning Home Depot, and denied as moot as to all other documents.”
“Dated: October 22, 2026”
- Checked by three models
The Court stayed the case with respect to Samaco, Marquez, and Price pending resolution of their arbitration proceedings, and ordered the parties to file a joint status report every 180 days.
“Dated: October 22, 2026”
“arbitration proceedings. The parties shall file a joint status report every 180 days to update the”
“GRANTED. Plaintiffs Paolo Roméo Samaco, Chelsea Marquez, and India Price must arbitrate”
“their claims, and the case is STAYED with respect to these plaintiffs pending resolution of their”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
In a separate order, the court granted Google's motion to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims.
“Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims, and the court granted that request in a separate order. (Dkt. No. 140.)”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved under Rule 12(b)(6) to dismiss the remaining named plaintiffs, who allege Google recorded their customer service calls with non-party Home Depot in violation of Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act.
“Google moves to dismiss the remaining named plaintiffs, who allege”
“Google has moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6).”
“Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act. (Dkt. No. 121.)”
“Google recorded their customer service calls with non-party Home Depot, in violation of”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The court heard oral argument, at which Plaintiffs' counsel was pressed and could not identify any reason the privacy policy does not give consent to Google to listen to calls as a service provider for Home Depot.
“When pressed at oral argument, Plaintiffs’ counsel”
“could not identify any reason the privacy policy does not give consent to Google to listen to calls”
“as a service provider for Home Depot, and the complaint affirmatively alleges that Google does”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims, and the court granted that request in a separate order (Dkt. No. 140).
“AI. (Dkt. No. 112 ¶¶ 56-103.) Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their”
“claims, and the court granted that request in a separate order. (Dkt. No. 140.) There are three”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved to compel named plaintiffs Paolo Roméo Samaco, Chelsea Marquez, and India Price to arbitrate their claims under their agreements with non-parties.
“Google has moved to compel three of the named plaintiffs—Paolo Roméo Samaco, Chelsea Marquez, and India Price—to arbitrate their claims pursuant to their agreements with the non- parties.1 (Dkt. No. 117.)”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google also moved, in the alternative, to dismiss; the order says this will be addressed in a separate order.
“Google also moved in the alternative to dismiss, which will be addressed in a separate order. (Dkt. No. 121.)”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Oral argument was held, at which counsel for Plaintiffs conceded that there was no longer any dispute about formation of an arbitration agreement as to Price.
“Price initially disputed whether Google had met its burden to show she formed a valid and binding arbitration agreement with Discover.”
“At oral argument, counsel for Plaintiffs conceded that there was no longer any dispute about formation as to Price.”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court held a hearing on the motion to dismiss, at which the discussion of the adequacy of Plaintiffs' allegations concerned the language in the non-parties' privacy policies.
“Indeed, at the hearing on the motion to dismiss, the discussion concerning the adequacy of Plaintiffs’ allegations was all about the language in those non-parties’ privacy policies”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved under Rule 12(b)(6) to dismiss the claims of plaintiffs Fox, Samish, and Barulich, who allege Google violated Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act by listening to their Home Depot customer service calls.
“Rule 12(b)(6).”
“Fox, Samish, and Barulich allege only one cause of action: that Google violated”
“Depot customer service calls. (Dkt. No. 112 ¶¶ 115-25.) Google has moved to dismiss under”
“Section 631(a) of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) by listening to their Home”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims.
“claims, and the court granted that request in a separate order. (Dkt. No. 140.) There are three”
“AI. (Dkt. No. 112 ¶¶ 56-103.) Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
In a separate order, the court granted Google's request to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims.
“AI. (Dkt. No. 112 ¶¶ 56-103.) Google moved to compel several plaintiffs to arbitrate their”
“claims, and the court granted that request in a separate order. (Dkt. No. 140.) There are three”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The court heard oral argument, at which Plaintiffs' counsel was pressed on the privacy policy's consent.
“could not identify any reason the privacy policy does not give consent to Google to listen to calls”
“Dkt. No. 123-5 at 6-7; Dkt. No. 123-6 at 7.) When pressed at oral argument, Plaintiffs’ counsel”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Google moved to compel named plaintiffs Paolo Roméo Samaco, Chelsea Marquez, and India Price to arbitrate their claims under their arbitration agreements with non-parties Verizon, Uber, and Discover.
“binding arbitration agreements with non-parties Verizon, Uber, and Discover, respectively.”
“Google has moved to compel three of the named plaintiffs—Paolo Roméo Samaco, Chelsea”
“Marquez, and India Price—to arbitrate their claims pursuant to their agreements with the non-”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
Oral argument was held, and at it counsel for Plaintiffs conceded that there was no longer any dispute about formation as to Price.
“Plaintiffs conceded that there was no longer any dispute about formation as to Price.”
“(Dkt. No. 134 ¶ 4-7; Dkt. No. 134-1 at 2, 3, 5-7.) At oral argument, counsel for”
- Date not statedChecked by three models
The Court held a hearing on the motion to dismiss, at which the discussion concerned the language in the non-parties' privacy policies.
“the language in those non-parties’ privacy policies, which underscores how the claims depend on”
“motion to dismiss, the discussion concerning the adequacy of Plaintiffs’ allegations was all about”
“7; Dkt. No. 119-10 at 7; Dkt. No. 119-11 at 9; Dkt. No. 120-2 at 3.) Indeed, at the hearing on the”